Research

Some people feel confident quickly and make a decision after gathering only a small amount of information. Others remain uncertain for longer and continue gathering information even when enough evidence is already available to make a decision. These differences in decision-making and information gathering are particularly pronounced in mental health conditions such as schizophrenia and obsessive-compulsive disorder .

The Deciding2Decide project investigates why differences in decision-making arise, how they are implemented in the brain, and whether they can be changed.

To address these questions, we combine different research approaches. We examine clinical characteristics and behaviour, use computational models to analyse decision-making processes, and apply MRI to investigate the underlying processes in the brain. In addition, we study fundamental mechanisms in experimental models. By investigating the same decision processes using different methods and across different groups, we aim to better understand how information gathering and decision-making work – and ultimately contribute to the development of new approaches to treating mental health conditions.

The research areas below provide more detail on how each part of the project contributes to this goal.

Why do some people make decisions with very little information, while others keep searching for more? Behaviour alone cannot tell us which processes give rise to these differences.

We use computational models to break information gathering down into its underlying components. These models allow us to investigate how people weigh new evidence, how confident they are in their decisions, and what determines when they stop gathering information and make a choice.

A common computational framework connects the different parts of Deciding2Decide, allowing us to compare decision-making mechanisms across behavioural experiments, neuroimaging, clinical populations and animal studies.

ComMod
Clincial_Intervention

Understanding why decision-making biases occur is only the first step. We also want to investigate whether they can be changed.

We develop and test brief psychological interventions designed to increase awareness of decision-making biases and promote more adaptive ways of gathering and evaluating information. After initially testing and refining these approaches online, we will investigate whether they can alter information-gathering behaviour in people with OCD and schizophrenia.

In parallel, we investigate the role of dopamine pharmacologically in healthy participants. Together with our cross-species research, these studies will help us determine which cognitive and neurobiological mechanisms are potentially modifiable and may ultimately provide new directions for more targeted interventions.

What happens in the brain while we gather information and decide when enough is enough?

Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), we investigate the neural mechanisms underlying information-gathering biases in people with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), schizophrenia and individuals without a psychiatric diagnosis. Rather than studying diagnostic categories in isolation, we take a transdiagnostic approach to identify mechanisms that may be shared across different mental health conditions.

The study is conducted in parallel in Tübingen and Bengaluru, allowing us to investigate these mechanisms across different cultural and socioeconomic contexts. Combining brain imaging with computational modelling will help us determine whether apparently different decision-making biases arise from shared or distinct neural processes.

fMRI
Maus

To understand the brain mechanisms behind information gathering in greater detail, we study related decision processes in mice.

Using a specially developed behavioural task, mice gather visual information before making a decision. This allows us to examine whether the fundamental computational principles identified in humans can also be observed in another species.

We focus particularly on the role of dopamine, a neurotransmitter involved in learning and decision-making. By recording dopamine activity in the prefrontal cortex and striatum and experimentally manipulating these signals, we can test their causal role in information gathering. Linking these experiments to the same computational framework used in our human studies enables us to connect behaviour, brain mechanisms and computation across species

Research on mental health should be shaped by the perspectives of people who have direct experience of the conditions being studied.

People with lived experience are therefore involved throughout Deciding2Decide, contributing to decisions about how our studies are designed, conducted, interpreted and communicated. Lived Experience Representatives are part of the project's decision-making structures, and local panels in Germany and India provide ongoing input into our clinical research.

We are also working together with people with lived experience on public engagement activities, including a project exploring questions and perspectives around the use of animal research in mental health research. This collaborative approach helps ensure that our research remains relevant, accessible and connected to the priorities of the people it ultimately aims to benefit.

LER